National Tribune
Sunday, 22 November 2026

ANC leadership must answer for election results — Mkhize

Story audio is generated using AI

Zweli Mkhize is not one to mince his words when it comes to the ANC and how the party is led — especially when he thinks it is being taken down a troublesome path.

A decade ago, he was among the first in then president Jacob Zuma’s inner circle to break ranks when the president’s Gupta friends seemed to be exerting undue influence over both party and state.

Six years later, now with President Cyril Ramaphosa at the helm, Mkhize led an unsuccessful campaign to replace him as ANC leader amid a raging scandal over the theft of undeclared US dollars from the president’s Phala Phala farm and an alleged attempted cover-up.

It is therefore no surprise that he has become one of a handful of currently serving members of the ANC’s national executive committee (NEC) to speak out publicly following the party’s dismal showing in the recent local government elections.

In a phone interview with the Sunday Times this week, Mkhize — who served as the ANC’s treasurer-general between 2012 and 2017 — was insistent that the NEC should account for the party’s electoral decline and confront its failure to retain voter confidence.

The former KwaZulu-Natal premier also blamed the party leadership for the ANC’s stalled “renewal project”, as well as its decision to form a government of national unity (GNU) with the DA.

Reflecting on the outcomes of the local government elections — which saw the party’s share of the vote decline to just over 30% — Mkhize said: “In a way, we have failed as the leadership of the ANC … The question [is]: have we led the ANC properly enough to sustain the support people have shown during difficult times?“

He said the NEC owed both ANC members and the public an explanation for the party’s decline, arguing that the election results demanded more than another round of internal discussions or attempts to shift blame.

“The leadership must be able to account to the members of the ANC and to society about what has happened to the ANC,” Mkhize said.

If you listen to the insults and attacks on the ANC by the members of the DA, you really feel that it’s a very poor reflection of parties that are in a coalition government

— Zweli Mkhize, ANC NEC member

He said the scale of the ANC’s electoral decline warranted a consultative conference at which the organisation could confront its failures and consider how to rebuild its support.

“I would say that if it means a consultative conference to reflect on this, it would be in order.”

Mkhize said the ANC had to accept the verdict of voters, regardless of whether it was favourable.

“If people were right to vote ANC and give us 60-something percent, and we thought the people had spoken, we must accept that people are still correct in voting the ANC into the low 30s. People cannot be wrong when they vote us down and be right when they vote us up.”

Though he stopped short of calling for specific leaders to resign, Mkhize said accountability had to begin with the structures responsible for the party’s direction. Resigning was a personal decision, he said, but the NEC could not evade responsibility for the election’s outcomes.

“The question of resignation or not is a personal decision … So I wouldn’t want to make a comment on what anyone else needs to do.

“However, I need to say that, as part of the NEC, we need to accept that we are accountable for the outcome of what has happened. And therefore we need to be able to face the membership of the organisation and society as a whole and say, ‘Here we are. What do you think should happen?’.

“But I believe it’s important that, as part of the introspection, we should not shy away from having to face the organisation, the branches, the constituents, and say, ‘Are we the ones that stand between the ANC victory and the confidence of the people?’

“If we are, then of course you can make your judgment on us. And I think that’s really what a democratic organisation would have to face.”

The leadership that you would have had in the mid-1990s has been eroded by a very strong shift in the character of the leadership in favour of factionalism, careerism, gatekeeping and distance from the people

In 2021, Mkhize had to resign as health minister in Ramaphosa’s cabinet following the Digital Vibes scandal, in which a company linked to a close associate of his was said to have irregularly received R150m from the department of health.

Mkhize has repeatedly maintained his innocence in the matter. Although the Special Investigating Unit (SIU) is still pursuing the recovery of the money through the courts, no-one has been convicted in relation to the case.

Accusations of corruption against high-ranking ANC leaders have undermined the party’s claim — since Ramaphosa took over — that it was undergoing a “renewal” and cleansing itself of tainted individuals.

But Mkhize believes renewal has stalled mainly because the leadership is incapable of implementing it.

“I believe the leadership must take responsibility for what has happened. President [Thabo] Mbeki said maybe we entrusted some of the renewal programmes to people who may not have been suitable to lead them. Maybe that is what we need to look at. Do we have the renewal programme in the hands of people suitable to lead it?

“That question has to be answered by ANC grassroots structures, which can say, ‘You have a challenge of declining confidence in the leadership. You have discussed, debated and agreed on the programme of renewal.’

“That renewal is needed is not a question — the question is whether we have been able to get the right people to do the leading of that programme.”

Mkhize said factionalism, careerism, gatekeeping and political patronage had fundamentally altered the character of ANC leadership, distancing it from ordinary members and communities.

Leadership had increasingly become about securing positions and protection within party structures, rather than earning support through work in communities. He also pointed to what he described as rampant incompetence in the ANC leadership.

“The leadership that you would have had in the mid-1990s has been eroded by a very strong shift in the character of the leadership in favour of factionalism, careerism, gatekeeping and distance from the people.

“People are not rising in positions of leadership because they have work on the ground that shows support from the grassroots community programmes but more because they have protection from the party bureaucracy, driven by factions.

“That is really what has caused the problem, and it’s not surprising when you see the response of the people.”

With the debate in ANC ranks intensifying over the future of the GNU, Mkhize has suggested that choosing the DA as a partner may not have been a good idea for the former liberation movement.

He said the ANC could have gone with its splinter parties and others whose world view is closer to its own. The fact that the ANC was unable to strike deals with the EFF, MK Party and other smaller parties after the 2024 general election was, he argued, an indictment of the current leadership.

We have been quite direct to say the best situation would have been first to look at the interests of the majority of the people and combine all those who represent those interests and then work together

He questioned why, if in 1994 the ANC could find a way of working with the National Party, it was so difficult to find common ground with its splinter organisations in 2024.

“It then begins to raise questions in the minds of many people. It’s not so much whether it’s the DA or the FF Plus, but it’s a question of saying, ‘How are you handling the issue of pulling everyone together if you can eject some amongst yourselves and embrace those whose programme is completely contradictory to what the majority black constituency is about?’

“That has raised a lot of debate. We have been quite direct to say the best situation would have been first to look at the interests of the majority of the people and combine all those who represent those interests and then work together,” Mkhize said.

He cited the ANC and IFP’s co-operation in KwaZulu-Natal in the 1990s as an example of parties putting the interests of the constituencies they represented ahead of their political differences.

“The two together had actually represented 84% of the population of the province. And therefore it was discussed that it was important to take the 84%, the interests of the 84%, into account and then co-operate,” he said.

“[The parties did this] not because they loved each other — the leaders were not in conflict … [but] because working together was the way of showing which constituencies constituted the priority for that particular government.”

The ANC, he added, had to ask whether the current GNU partnership was delivering for communities or becoming increasingly defined by public disagreements and political hostility.

He also expressed concern about the increasingly hostile exchanges between the ANC and the DA, warning that the public conduct of parties in government was undermining confidence in their working relationship.

“If you listen to the insults and attacks on the ANC by members of the DA, you really feel that it’s a very poor reflection of parties that are in a coalition government.

“We’ve done studies to look at how coalition governments work in different countries. One of the issues that has been raised, which from where I sit becomes a matter of concern, is that coalition governments should at least have [the] effect of bringing harmony among the members of the public and also avoid what in some countries they call negative parliamentarism, where people just fight.

“They’re supposed to be together, but when they go to the public, they issue such conflicting statements about how their relationship is, to the extent that you actually stop believing in their relationship because of the way they behave.

“So, sitting from outside, we can see it’s a very uneasy relationship. And whether the parties inside who are still part of the cabinet feel this is a working relationship or not, only they can tell us.

“But from where we sit, it has got unexpected tensions and hostility that do not really reflect people in a good relationship.”

Originally reported by TimesLIVE.