ANC plots life without DA: GNU on the line as coalition talks start
The ANC and the DA go into their coalition negotiations today with a cloud hanging over the future of the government of national unity (GNU) after the ANC’s national executive committee (NEC) meeting this week heard calls for the arrangement to be reviewed.
Party insiders say that a majority of those who spoke at Thursday’s meeting of the NEC — the ANC’s highest decision-making body between national conferences — seized the moment to revive calls for an end to the GNU in its current form, with some even arguing that the DA’s inclusion in the arrangement was directly responsible for the ANC’s decline in the November 4 municipal elections.
The ANC spent yesterday holding marathon meetings with other parties as it considered all options in its scramble to secure a deal.
The negotiations come as several municipalities prepare to elect new mayors this week, putting pressure on parties to conclude agreements.
Johannesburg and Tshwane are expected to hold their inaugural council sittings on Thursday.
Reliable ANC NEC members told the Sunday Times that most of those who spoke at the meeting were adamant that, among the coalition options being considered, the DA should be the “last resort”, with ActionSA said to be the first preference.
We aren’t ANC members and don’t involve ourselves in the internal affairs of the ANC or any other party. We have had high-level talks about the required principles to stabilise government and the policy programme to rescue basic services with all parties
— Ashor Sarupen, DA federal council chair
They indicated that the “posture” of NEC members was clear: they would call for the DA’s removal from the GNU at their next meeting, scheduled for late November or early December.
In many of the hung metros, particularly the three in Gauteng (Johannesburg, Tshwane and Ekurhuleni), the ANC would need either the DA or ActionSA to form stable councils, as the party wants to avoid fragile multiparty coalitions. But it has emerged that, during the NEC meeting, there was a strong push to avoid partnerships with the DA at municipal level.
This stance is said to have been supported by ANC president Cyril Ramaphosa, who apparently told the meeting that he was “tired of the DA”, as the blue party was constantly second-guessing his party’s policies, including litigating against it.
But the DA appears unmoved by threats from the ANC to dump it, saying a deal between the two parties remains viable.
DA federal council chair Ashor Sarupen — who is leading the party’s negotiating team — said they were not aware of any ANC plan to dump the blue party as a co-governing partner.
“We aren’t ANC members and don’t involve ourselves in the internal affairs of the ANC or any other party,” said Sarupen. “We have had high-level talks about the required principles to stabilise government and the policy programme to rescue basic services with all parties.
“We have not pitted parties against each other in our talks. We have not gone into specific municipalities as this isn’t a game of horse trading; it’s about governing for people and improving lives. We will negotiate with all parties in good faith and on a shared programme of action for improved service delivery, which hopefully we can reach agreement on.”
The ANC’s coalition talks team has been presented with four options as it negotiates with other parties.
The first is prioritising a local government of unity (LGU) option, on the grounds that this would produce stable governments in all eight metros.
Under this option, the ANC would be able to lobby for its mayoral candidates in Buffalo City, Mangaung and eThekwini, while backing DA mayors in Johannesburg, Tshwane, Ekurhuleni and Nelson Mandela Bay, where the DA is the largest party.
However, the NEC meeting deemed this the least preferred option after most of those who spoke during the discussion expressed misgivings about working with the DA.
The second option was for the ANC to go into an alliance with only the DA, ActionSA and the IFP. This would still secure a majority in all the metros, including eThekwini, while producing a more manageable coalition with fewer parties involved. However, some in the NEC felt this option would give the other three parties too much leverage over policy direction.
The NEC was also presented with the possibility of a separate agreement with ActionSA and several smaller parties, excluding the DA.
While such a coalition could form a government in six metros, it would not be able to govern in eThekwini or Cape Town, where the DA has an absolute majority.
This option’s biggest disadvantage, however, is that it would require the involvement of many smaller parties, raising the spectre of instability in the cities governed by such coalitions. The legitimacy of those governments would also be undermined by the exclusion of the largest party in cities such as Johannesburg, Tshwane and the Nelson Mandela Bay metro.
Moreover, some NEC members argued, this option could set a precedent for future provincial and national elections in which the ANC could be excluded from government even when it had obtained the highest number of votes.
The final option was to enter into a confidence-and-supply agreement, under which the largest party would be allowed to form a minority government in council while the other parties remained in opposition. In this arrangement, the ANC would support the election of DA or ActionSA mayoral candidates in the Gauteng metros in return for the DA’s support for ANC mayors in Mangaung and Buffalo City.
However, an NEC member said the biggest risk for the ANC with this approach was that it would give the DA and ActionSA an opportunity to consolidate their support in Gauteng ahead of the 2029 elections.
Several NEC insiders said the meeting had resolved that the ANC should adopt a position of “tactical flexibility” in coalition negotiations, engaging all parties while avoiding any commitment to working with the DA.
“We decided on a tactical flexibility that when we enter these negotiations we will not have a position,” said one of the sources. “We must be open and engage all parties, especially the MK Party, EFF, SACP, PA, UDM and ActionSA, but also not exclude the DA.
“We felt that by excluding the DA from the negotiations we would be setting ourselves up for problems. The feeling is that we must not elevate the DA, but we cannot rule them out.”
A coalition with the DA has not benefited the ANC. It’s been difficult because the DA … works for its own agenda outside that of government. Second, we are failing in explaining to the black population our reasons for working with the DA
— ANC insider
The sources said the decision could have implications for the future of the national coalition, with some within the ANC questioning whether the arrangement had delivered the benefits originally promised.
They said Ramaphosa had also told the meeting that, during door-to-door campaigns, he had been questioned by party members who were unhappy with the ANC’s decision to work with the DA.
“The reasons why the NEC took this decision when it comes to the DA are varied. One … is that a coalition with the DA has not benefited the ANC. It’s been difficult because the DA … works for its own agenda outside that of government. Second, we are failing in explaining to the black population our reasons for working with the DA.”
When it went into the GNU with the DA, the ANC had said it wanted stability.
“We could not work with some parties because they were unstable, and instability would affect the economy. We said this would further exacerbate the high levels of unemployment and poverty. So we looked at the DA as a stable party that would make it easy for us to work with capital and people who hold the purse in our country. We were also conscious that we did not want to antagonise the West and Donald Trump.
“But where are we now? Can we still say that working with them is to make sure that the West is not hostile? The West is very hostile, and their hostility is exacerbated by the DA, among others. They go and campaign against us with the US, said the sources.”
A concern was that if the DA were given a metro, they would be “telling the population every day that they are fixing a metro run down by the ANC, and telling the population how deep the rot is, forgetting that these metros have been in unstable coalitions”.
“If we allow that in Joburg, that will be the end of us. Our view in the NEC was that there is no value in working with the DA. Whatever we thought we would gain from an arrangement with them, not even half of these reasons to enter a coalition with them are happening.”
One senior leader said the ANC had struggled to justify its partnership with the DA, particularly to its black constituency, as the party continued to oppose key elements of the ANC’s transformation agenda.
The president is irritated with the DA leader and even blue-ticked his requests for an audience after the elections. The president has told him that he must direct any requests for meetings to Luthuli House because he is not in government
— ANC NEC member
Another NEC member said the party’s ultimate objective was to reassess the national arrangement, with municipal coalition negotiations providing an opportunity to begin implementing its new approach.
“Our endgame is national. We want to start implementing this decision at municipal level first. Some of us are hoping that they [the DA] may be irritated by our stance at local level so much so that they choose to withdraw from the GNU.
“If they don’t, the NEC took a decision that we will have another meeting early next year where they will do a comprehensive analysis of the DA’s involvement in national government.”
The member said the ANC could still work with the DA in Mangaung, but only if there were no viable alternatives.
“Where we can survive without them, we don’t need them.”
The growing tensions have also affected relations between Ramaphosa and DA leader Geordin Hill-Lewis, with an ANC insider claiming the president was irritated by Hill-Lewis’s attempts to bypass Luthuli House and communicate with him directly.
“The president is irritated with the DA leader and even blue-ticked his requests for an audience after the elections. The president has told him that he must direct any requests for meetings to Luthuli House because he is not in government. Party matters are addressed at Luthuli House.”
The insider said it had been a different matter with former DA leader John Steenhuisen.
“He was a minister, so he was able to ask for meetings with the president to discuss government and cabinet matters. The president cannot discuss matters of government with Hill-Lewis.
“It’s strange that he undermines this line, and I think he is losing favour with the president.”
The insider said Hill-Lewis had further annoyed ANC leaders during the election campaign when he told journalists that he wished Ramaphosa would take a more active role in coalition negotiations.