National Tribune
Tuesday, 17 November 2026
Cricket

LUKE ALFRED | Reverse swing’s terminal reversal

Story audio is generated using AI

Those of us who watched the first day’s play between South Africa and Bangladesh at the Wanderers on Sunday will have noticed a glaring absence: the reverse swing.

Wiaan Mulder shaped the ball away from the right-hander from time to time, and it occasionally jagged off the pitch when it hit a crack. As far as reverse swing was concerned, however, there was none. It would have appeared — to coin a cheeky phrase — to have reversed out of Test cricket completely, now part of the game’s past like underarm bowling and covered wickets.

There’s only one reason for this, and that’s the Australian ball-tampering kerfuffle on the second day of the third Test at Newlands in 2018 and the implications for those now caught tampering with the ball. We won’t rehash the sequence of events here, except to note that the coals of the affair have again been raked over as a result of the recent release of Usman Khawaja’s autobiography, Sabr.

In it, he claims that everyone knew what was going on at Newlands, a claim Pat Cummins — in the dressing room at the time, but the Aussie captain now — denies. “They’re complete and utter nonsense,” said Cummins of Khawaja’s allegations.

David Warner, the vice-captain in 2018, has come out in support of Khawaja, saying he believed “Pat threw Usman under the bus” with his comments about Khawaja’s revelations. Chadd Sayers, 12th man at Newlands, has admitted to taking the sandpaper off the field, while adding that he wasn’t even interviewed in Cricket Australia’s investigation, which Warner called “botched”. This suggests that Cricket Australia tried to move beyond the incident as quickly as possible.

Khawaja, who was born in Islamabad in 1986 but whose parents moved to Sydney when he was four, has added detail to his claim that the dressing room knew. He and Sayers have said that there was a discussion after the day’s play for between an hour and 90 minutes about taking “collective responsibility” for the incident, an incident Cummins doesn’t recall.

This idea of collective responsibility was scotched by two players he didn’t name. “I knew who those two guys were, and it was ludicrous; out of everyone, it was them. It showed me their true colours though. When the going got tough, all they cared about was themselves,” wrote Khawaja in the book.

We don’t know who these two players were, but they were unlikely to have been skipper Steve Smith and Warner. Smith had a mandate to lead, care for and represent his side, and Warner was his vice-captain. Once the sandpaper was out of the pocket — as it were — they would have been in the line of fire anyway. To fail to take responsibility would be tantamount to losing their teammates’ respect.

This leaves only the bowlers, Nathan Lyon, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Starc. The first two have been notably silent through this spasm of claim and denial, with Starc (who didn’t play in the fourth Test at the Wanderers in 2018) appearing equivocal when he recently gave his version of events.

Faf du Plessis, the Proteas skipper in 2018, told an Australian cricket podcast that the South Africans became so suspicious of Starc’s reverse during the first Test at Kingsmead that they trained binoculars on him. “Starc was a jet with the reverse swinging ball in the first Test,” he said.

Du Plessis was happy to admit that all the teams were ball-tampering in an effort to get the older ball to reverse swing at the time. He likened it to speeding, where everyone does it and hopes they won’t get caught.

Du Plessis’ candour is useful because it widens the debate. Cricket’s moral architecture belongs in a different age. Nowadays we put men (and women) in hyper-competitive and carefully scrutinised celebrity environments where they often earn outrageous sums and we expect them to be paragons of virtue. The hypocrisy might be ours.

Reverse can be achieved by legitimate means; it’s just more pronounced when you use Vaseline or mints or bottle tops or lollies. I shouldn’t admit this, but I miss it. Reverse has backed out of the game when it should be back in it.

Business Day

Originally reported by Business Day.