National Tribune
Friday, 20 November 2026
Politics

SIBONGAKONKE SHOBA | Cruel mathematics of coalition politics

Story audio is generated using AI

Poor Helen Zille. She left her home in the leafy suburb of Rosebank in Cape Town and moved to rapidly deteriorating Emmarentia in Johannesburg. Magogo was on a mission to save Joburgers from themselves.

She launched the “Get Joburg Working For All” campaign, slipped into her blue overalls and got her hands dirty. Sometimes she took the campaign to extraordinary lengths, diving into cavernous potholes and canoeing through flooded streets.

It was a spectacle, but it was also effective. For weeks, people spoke about the deterioration of a city that was once the pride of Mzansi. Even traditional ANC voters paused to consider whether the former Cape Town mayor might be the saviour Johannesburg had been waiting for.

The campaign helped propel the DA to its strongest performance in the city, making it the largest party in the metro. But, in the cruel mathematics of coalition politics, Zille now appears destined to be one of the biggest losers. Despite the DA emerging as the largest party, she has given up on the mayoral chain.

If reports are accurate, the ANC, ActionSA, EFF, MK Party and several smaller parties are close to finalising a deal that would leave the DA out in the cold. So much for salvation.

The ANC is believed to have offered ActionSA the mayorships of Johannesburg and Tshwane in exchange for control of Ekurhuleni. These parties would then co-govern most of the hung metros.

So Zille won’t save us, after all.

I often chuckle when listening to radio callers boast about how they “removed” the ANC from power by voting for another party. This narrative usually comes from supporters of ActionSA, MK Party or DA.

The reality that has emerged since the elections tells a very different story. The ANC remains deeply entrenched in South African politics. Almost all the parties that campaigned under the banner of change have spent the post-election period scrambling to secure meetings with Luthuli House to strike a deal.

Far from isolating the ANC, many of these parties have demonstrated just how dependent they remain on it to achieve power. Many of the voters who imagined a new political order are now watching opposition parties negotiate with the very party they claimed was responsible for the country’s decline.

The notion that these parties offer a substantially superior alternative is also open to scrutiny. The MK Party, for instance, did not even bother presenting a formal manifesto to voters. Its campaign message was largely reduced to the slogan “Sithatha omasipala”. Beyond that, voters were expected to place their faith in former president Jacob Zuma’s personality and popularity.

The party also lacks meaningful internal democracy. Zuma appoints its leaders, and key decisions are made at his Nkandla headquarters.

ActionSA is not much different. While the party produced a manifesto promising to “fix” South Africa, internal democracy appears equally limited. Like Zuma, Herman Mashaba exercises considerable control over appointments and leadership positions.

The EFF, on the other hand, has the commander-in-chief. Enough said.

One would have thought that South Africans had learned enough from political movements across the continent, where dominant leaders centralise power, weaken internal checks and punish dissent.

The DA, meanwhile, continues to struggle to convince enough voters outside the Western Cape that it can be trusted to govern alone. Despite years of growth, it has failed to shake off the perception that it remains a “white party”.

It helps explain why, despite widespread frustration with the ANC, the DA still could not secure the outright majority needed to govern Johannesburg.

Mashaba may soon return to the mayor’s office, while Nasiphi Moya could retain the mayoral chain in Tshwane. Both metros enjoyed relatively stable coalition arrangements before the elections. The term ahead appears far less predictable.

Should these coalition agreements extend beyond Gauteng, they could also pave the way for the MK Party to form governments in eThekwini and other KwaZulu-Natal municipalities, where it secured the largest share of the vote.

The instability many warned about may soon become reality.

South Africans appear to be on course to get the governments they voted for. Whether they will get the change they expected is an entirely different question.

Originally reported by Sowetan.